Exploring the realm of spiced/herbed/vegetable beer, Schlafly Pumpkin Ale by The Saint Louis Brewery promises a concoction that captures the essence of autumn. With a focus on infusing harvest spices into a full-bodied sweetness reminiscent of pumpkin pie, this beer aims to deliver a flavorful experience.

Tasting Experience

Appearance: Upon pouring this 8% ABV ale into a snifter, the dark red hue with a noticeable absence of bubbles or head sets the stage. The body’s translucency allows a gentle play of light, inviting the drinker into its world.

Aroma: The olfactory journey is dominated by the anticipated fragrance of pumpkin pie and its accompanying spices. The brew achieves precisely what it sets out to, leaving little room for additional nuances in the aromatic profile.

Taste: Gingerbread and pumpkin notes take the forefront, accompanied by a subtle hop spice that complements the overall flavor profile. The integration of the 8% alcohol content is skillfully executed, contributing to a well-balanced taste experience.

Mouthfeel: A medium-bodied texture with modest carbonation characterizes the beer’s mouthfeel. This choice enhances the overall drinking experience without overshadowing the dominant flavors.

Critical Evaluation

While Schlafly Pumpkin Ale successfully embodies the quintessential characteristics of a pumpkin ale, it adheres closely to the conventions of the genre. The execution is commendable, offering a flavorful and well-integrated brew. However, for those seeking a departure from the traditional pumpkin ale, this offering may not venture far off the beaten path.


In the realm of pumpkin ales, Schlafly’s rendition stands as a solid representative. Its adherence to the expected flavor profile and seamless integration of spices make it a reliable choice for enthusiasts of this seasonal variety. Though not groundbreaking, the beer showcases a mastery of its genre, delivering a satisfying and familiar pumpkin-infused experience.