The Rhinegeist Peach Dodo pours from the 12oz can with a crystal-clear straw color, accompanied by a thicker white foam that impressively lingers for about two minutes—a noteworthy feat for a kettle sour. The packaging date of 4/18/19 is clearly visible, making this review based on a five-week-old sample.


The aroma of Peach Dodo is dominated by a potent peach scent, reminiscent of a peach-scented candle. While undeniably intense and lovely, it tends to lean towards a one-note profile, lacking the underlying funkiness that would typically characterize a sour ale.


In terms of flavor, Peach Dodo ventures into intense sour territory, bordering on the line between enjoyable and overly puckering. The prominent citric acidity, reminiscent of lemon juice, takes center stage, overshadowing the nuanced peach flavors. Despite the beer’s name and the strong peach aroma, the taste experience might leave one searching for the peach notes amidst the high acidity.


Peach Dodo manages to maintain its enjoyable character despite the intense acidity. However, it could benefit from a more traditional gose profile, allowing the buoyant salinity and lactic acid component to shine through. The beer’s acidity level leans more towards that of a barrel-aged sour ale than a classic kettle sour.


Rhinegeist’s Peach Dodo is undeniably popular, delivering a punch of peach in both aroma and acidity. However, it veers towards a citric (lemon) focus, missing the balance typically found in traditional gose styles. While still enjoyable, the beer’s deviation from a more nuanced gose profile may disappoint purists seeking the subtleties of the style.


For those exploring fruited goses, Anderson Valley’s offerings, such as Blood Orange Gose, Briney Melon, Cherry, and Framboise Rose, serve as excellent examples of the style. The Sixpoint Jammer series also impresses with its take on the fruited gose style. Availability permitting, these alternatives are worth exploring for a well-rounded comparison.


Peach Dodo’s popularity can be attributed to its robust peach aroma and assertive acidity. However, its departure from a more traditional gose balance and its citric-centric focus may not appeal to enthusiasts seeking the classic nuances of the style. While it remains a clean and straightforward option for those less inclined towards kettle sours, gose purists might find the beer lacking in certain aspects of the style.


In the realm of beer reviews, striking a balance between providing valuable insights for potential consumers and constructive feedback for breweries is crucial. Critical reviews, when well-articulated, serve as valuable quality control, offering businesses an opportunity to refine and enhance their products. Consumers benefit from honest assessments that guide their purchasing decisions, while businesses gain valuable insights to improve their offerings. It’s important to approach critical reviews with respect for the business and its reputation, recognizing that feedback, both positive and negative, can contribute to the continuous improvement of the craft beer industry.