Upon pouring the 12 oz. can of 21st Amendment Hell or High Watermelon into specialized glassware, the initial impression is clear and pale straw-colored. The beer presents itself as heavily carbonated, generating a soda-like, white foam that eventually settles into a persistent meringue-textured layer. Despite the promising start, the visual appeal leans towards a watery aesthetic.

Aroma: Doughy with a Twist of Lemon

The aroma of Hell or High Watermelon is an interesting medley, with doughy notes accompanied by volatiles reminiscent of lemon soap and candy corn. This peculiar combination raises some initial doubts about the beer’s aromatic profile. It prompts contemplation on whether it might be more palatable when experienced straight from the can, as the aroma doesn’t immediately align with expectations of a refreshing watermelon-infused brew.

Taste: A Melon Melange with a Swift Departure

The flavor profile kicks off with subtle honeydew melon and the green, mildly bitter undertones of watermelon rind. However, the promising start takes a brief detour in the mid-palate, where a sudden appearance of watermelon Jolly Rancher is noted but fades away swiftly. The final impression leaves much to be desired, as the beer concludes with a somewhat bland character akin to seltzer water, lacking the enduring watermelon essence.

Mouthfeel: Light-Bodied, Almost Too Light

Passing the brew around to unsuspecting beer enthusiasts revealed varying opinions. One blind taster picked up on fruity notes, while another simply described it as watery with a resemblance to wheat ale. Despite being classified as a wheat ale, the experience doesn’t align seamlessly with the expected characteristics of the genre. The overall consensus is that Hell or High Watermelon is overly light-bodied, bordering on weakness, and fails to deliver a pronounced watermelon flavor.

Overall: Weakness in Flavor and Body

In the grand scheme of watermelon-infused summer beers, Hell or High Watermelon falls short of expectations. The beer lacks the robust body needed to complement its watermelon infusion, resulting in a beverage that fails to leave a lasting impression. When compared to counterparts like New Belgium’s Juicy Watermelon, it becomes apparent that Hell or High Watermelon not only lacks the desired watermelon kick but also falls behind in the foundational wheat ale base. For those seeking a more fulfilling watermelon beer experience, alternative options may prove more satisfying.